I don’t want to say I told you so, but…

If you watch American Idol and didn’t see last night’s performance, I’m going to give you fair warning: There might be a spoiler here. Heck, it might have even been a spoiler when I mentioned it a few days ago. Either way, last night Jason Castro brought new lows to American Idol just like I said. It so depressing that he’s made it this far when people like Carly Smithson, Michael Johns, and even Brooke White still could have had a better shot than he did.

I don’t think I’ve ever seen Simon Cowell go off so hard in a post-performance review. And everything he said was dead on. It was even awesome watching Paula stumble through her response because she was having a hard time finding anything nice to say about the performance. Instead, she just told him she loved him.

Here’s his second performance, complete with forgetting of lyrics. Watch it while you can—it’s possible it’s going to get taken down pretty soon:

Don’t forget: This is the Top 4. These are supposed to be the BEST FOUR PEOPLE LEFT IN AMERICA OMG. That performance looked like someone who had just made it to Hollywood with a decent voice and an ability to play the guitar. Simon summed it up best when he was done: “You had better pack your bags.”